Sunday 25 October 2020

BOOK REVIEW : Meeting God in Mark by Rowan Williams


A short and rich guide to a short and rich gospel! Rowan Williams explains that the purpose of this book is to “offer suggestions for a slow reading of what notoriously feels like a rushed and packed text" and we used it accordingly, over a six week study group at St Stephen Walbrook this autumn. For those looking for a more formal structure and reading guide, the appendix contains questions for group discussion around the themes covered in each chapter and a weekly reading guide, followed by a short reflection.

Williams describes Mark as a “Cinderella among the gospels” - for too long ignored in the lectionary of the church and by commentators. Perhaps inspired by Mark's fondness for groups of three, the book is divided into three parts; an introduction, a central section on the ministry of Jesus and the final chapter focussing on the passion.

Regime Change

The first chapter presents the key themes of the gospel, which Rowan Williams explains begins in the style of an official proclamation; such as that announcing the rule of a new Emperor. This is a story about "regime change" - an announcement that God is taking over. There is no account of the birth of Jesus in Mark; he walks on to the stage fully formed and ready to go. Regime Change has begun.

Messianic secret

Whist the gospel starts with a proclamation, Jesus attempts to conceal his identity, especially after performing healing miracles; this is known by scholars as the “Messianic secret”. Jesus does not wish to be known as a miracle worker or base his authority on working miracles (like travelling preachers of the time). Jesus wants people to recognise what is unique about his mission. To this end, trust or belief is always required from those with whom he works; trust in Him heals. This is why Jesus can’t heal anyone in his hometown; the people of Galilee do not trust him.

Relationship

Rowan Williams explains that this is the secret of Mark's gospel story -  the event that alters the shape of what is possible for everyone, everywhere and in every time is brought about not by power and force - but by a trusting, loving relationship. A relationship which we are to share.

About Mark

In the first section of the book we also learn about the traditions associated with the author of the gospel - that Mark was secretary to St Peter and took down and re-ordered his teaching in Rome at a time when Christians were being persecuted, although others make a strong case for one of the trading settlements in North Africa as the location where the gospel was first written. Rowan Williams explains that the style of Greek that is used by Mark is that of a trader not one of the intelligensia; he writes in “Daily Mail” Greek! One tradition claims Mark had short fingers - although it is not clear if this is an explanation for the brevity of this, the shortest gospel, or a description of the author’s physical attributes, or both!

Ministry and misunderstandings

The central section of the book explores the ministry of Jesus. Rowan Williams explains that compared to the other gospels, Mark is “light on teaching”; he doesn’t want to distract us with interesting ideas or miracles, he wants us to focus on “the person of Jesus and the relationship you might have with him - through which radical change comes about.”

But the gospel does contain several parables, which are often misunderstood even by those closest to Jesus. At one point Jesus explains that he deliberately speaks in parables so people can’t understand him! Rowan Williams suggests this is a case of Jesus being ironic. Jesus does want us to understand - that is the whole purpose of the parables.

Parables, Williams explains, are comparisons (they sometimes begin with the phrase “the Kingdom of Heaven is like...”) Jesus describes the work of God in comparison to recognizable natural processes (a seed, a lamp). He is telling us that if we want to understand more about the nature of God, we have to open our eyes to the clues all around us.

The parables reveal the nature of Gods transforming power; which is at work within the processes of the world and from the heart out, not the top down (like light slowly entering a dark room; not like thunder and lightening). This message would have been comforting for the first readers of the Gospel; “Mark is writing for a church fearful because the miracles aren't coming thick and fast. For a community experiencing fear and persecution. A life where God is not stepping down to solve their problems.”

Passion

The final section of the book focuses on the passion of Jesus - which, Rowan Williams explains, has been the focus of the gospel all along (“Mark is a passion gospel with a long introduction”).

The pace of the narrative slows, with events occurring in fewer locations and Jesus left more and more isolated and alone. One explanation for this change in pace is that the text is based on an early liturgy used by the first Christians as they walked the streets of Jerusalem - similar to the Stations of the Cross. This might account for the increased use of Old Testament quotations or references in this part of Mark’s gospel.

Rowan Williams highlights the differences between Marks account of Jesus’s passion and the other gospels. In John, for instance, Jesus responds eloquently to the challenges leveled against him. Mark lets the sham of the political and religious authority play out before Jesus who, stripped of everything and in the middle of this “meaningless nightmare” speaks only once. As Rowan Williams explains; “responding to the high priest, Jesus makes his one utterly unambiguous claim : “I am” (the annointed one, Son of the Blessed).”

This is when the Messianic secret is revealed - by a “God whose authority appears only when all worldly power has been stripped away....God has chosen to be manifest at the lowest, weakest point of human experience.”

“Jesus’s execution is the price that is paid to free us once and for all from the fantasy that God's power is just like ours.”

“Jesus dismantles the myth of power that holds us prisoner.”

The end is also the beginning

Rowan Williams notices the irony in the ending of the gospel (the original or ‘short’ ending at 16.8 : “So they went out and fled from the tomb, for terror and amazement had seized them; and they said nothing to anyone, for they were afraid.”)

Whilst throughout the Gospel Jesus has told people not to reveal who he truly is, after the encounter with the angel in the empty tomb, who specifically tells the three women to go and tell the disciples about the resurrection of Jesus, nobody wants to talk about it! Clearly, they did so eventually - or we would not be reading the Gospel today!

The resurrection of Jesus re-created our relationship with God - a relationship of trust and love. The end of the Gospel of Mark invites us to go back to to the beginning; to tell the story ourselves; to make the gospel part of the narrative of our lives.

Links

Some Start: Stop reflections based on our discussions at our Autumn Study Group:
Keep Awake (Mark 13)
Restored to his right mind (Mark 5.1-20)

Another author, Richard Burridge, has written a number of books on the Gospels, one of which I wrote about at this link

No comments:

Post a Comment

Sermon - Sing that Bittersweet Symphony

Marian Anderson by William H. Johnston, 1945 (Smithsonian Museum) A sermon given during Holy Communion (BCP) at St Giles-in-the-Fields on Su...